Damages in construction contracts
Damages for breach of contract are intended to be compensatory, that is to say, so far as they can, they are intended to place the innocent party in the same position that they would have been in had the other party performed their contractual promises (see British Westinghouse Electric Company Ltd v. Underground Electric Railways).
In contrast, an award of damages in respect of tortious liability is intended to place the innocent party back in the position they were before the breach of the duty. Awards of damages for breach of contract may therefore be greater than awards of damages in tort.
In Muirhead v Industrial Tank Specialists Ltd, M entered into a contract with a third party for the supply of pumps to be used at M's lobster farm. The electric motors for the pumps were supplied by ITS. The motors failed causing the pumps to fail, which resulted in the death of M's lobsters. There was no contract between M and ITS and M brought proceedings in negligence.
M claimed three heads of damage: the value of the dead lobsters; the loss of profits on those lobsters; the loss of profits that would have been earned by M's business had the pumps functioned properly. It was held that M was entitled to recover the first two heads of damage but not the third head of damage. The court considered that the third head of damage might have been recoverable had there been a contract between M and ITS.
Damages may be general damages, which can be assessed in an approximate figure, or special damages, which represent past pecuniary loss and have to be calculated and pleaded with sufficient particularity so as not to take the defendant by surprise at trial. Further, damages may include future damages, that is to say those which it is anticipated are likely to flow from the breach of contract.
Future damages are known as prospective loss and must be claimed at the same time as past or present loss in respect of the same breach of contract (see Conquer v Boot). This rule does not apply to breaches of different promises within the same contract or breaches of recurring obligations; such breaches are considered to give rise to separate causes of action.
Damages for breach of contract (which includes liquidated and ascertained damages) must be distinguished from claims arising under the terms of the contract, for example a claim for direct loss and expense. Such claims are not subject to the general principles on damages set out below. They are however subject to the rules of construction of a contract.
The parties to a contract may agree on the amount of damages to be awarded in the event of a breach of contract. Such damages are known as liquidated and ascertained damages and are commonplace in construction contracts, usually related to the completion obligations of the contractor.
Provided the agreed sum is a genuine pre-estimate of loss and not a penalty, it will be enforced by the courts (see Dunlop Ltd v New Garage Co Ltd). Damages may also include consequential losses. Consequential losses, often referred to as 'economic loss', are losses such as loss of profit, which are not directly related to physical damage (see Muirhead).
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
- Betterment.
- Breach of contract.
- Causation.
- Collateral warranty.
- Consequential losses.
- Construction contract.
- Contract v tort.
- Decennial liability.
- Expectation interest and reliance expenditure.
- Joinder.
- Liquidated damages.
- Liquidated v unliquidated damages.
- Loss and expense.
- Measure of damages.
- Mitigation of loss.
- Penalty.
- Record keeping.
- Remoteness.
- Substantial and other damages.
- The distinction between liquidated damages clauses and penalty clauses.
- Unliquidated damages.
Featured articles and news
The benefits of writing articles for your organisation
How to create a profile for your organisation and publish for free.
No Falls Week. The importance of safe working at height
What to expect and what is on offer to avoid accidents.
Scottish Government action to reach net-zero targets
Retrofit expert group highlight critical actions needed.
A forward thinking, inclusive global community of members.
From engineered product life-spans, to their extension.
Circular economy in the built environment
A brief description from 2021. Where are we now?
Mental Health Awareness Week with ABS
Architects Benevolent Society programme of activity.
CLC publishes domestic retrofit competency framework
Roadmap of Skills for net zero.
May 13-19: Moving more for our mental health.
Understanding is key to conservation.
Open industry engagement survey seeks responses
Institutions and the importance of engagement.
National Retrofit Hub unveils new guide
Digital Building Logbooks and Retrofit: An Introduction.
Enhancing construction site reporting efficiency
Through digitisation and the digital revolution.
Noise in the built environment
BSRIA guide TG 20/2021.
17,000 people suffer conditions as a result of exposure to excessive noise at work.
Turning down the noise: Auditory health
A pervasive risk with far-reaching consequences.
Getting the most out of heat pumps and heating
How heat pumps work and how they work best.
Electrotechnical excellence, now open for entries.