Seasonal and continuous commissioning of buildings
So the building is complete. The occupants are settled in and all systems are running. This is usually the time when the project team has disbanded, left site and moved onto the next job, but it is also the time when the building most needs attention. The commissioning activities after occupation can be split into three main categories:
- Fine-tuning.
- Seasonal commissioning.
- Continuous commissioning.
Fine-tuning may still be needed even if the building's systems are meeting the requirements of the specification. The building’s occupants will judge the actual comfort levels, not the setpoints in the specification.
Fine-tuning requires a good forensic eye to be able to spot performance problems that lurk just below the radar of the defects team. Activities might involve tweaking PIR settings on automated lighting, or adjusting ventilation grilles, dampers and controls.
Designers often don’t appreciate the extent to which glare is a problem on elevations that don’t get direct sunlight. This may lead to extra internal blinds, which in itself may require the control protocols for motorised fanlights to be altered.
Fine-tuning activities can usually be greatly informed by structured occupant feedback. This could be done formally using a standard questionnaire such as the Building Use Studies (BUS) method, or less formally by the designers developing a rapport with the occupants. Feedback can highlight issues that are very difficult to detect otherwise, such as draughts or local discomfort problems.
As its title implies, seasonal commissioning involves re-commissioning heating systems in winter and mechanical cooling systems in summer. But seasonal commissioning may also be applied to other systems, such as motorised windows and active solar-shading devices any building system affected by seasonal changes. Ideally, the original project team (or independent commissioning engineer, if appointed) should remain engaged to perform the seasonal commissioning.
The BREEAM environmental assessment scheme awards credits for the adoption of seasonal commissioning. In practice, looking at the projects in the Carbon Trust’s Low Carbon Buildings Performance programme (LCBP), it was very difficult to distinguish seasonal commissioning activities from continuous commissioning, or activities that were following on after handover.
Continuous commissioning is the umbrella process that covers all the other forms of commissioning. It involves the building and its systems being continuously monitored, either via the building management system (BMS) or through the use of dedicated logging devices. Systems can be re- commissioned or adjusted if performance isn’t meeting requirements.
Continuous commissioning has become increasingly popular. The inherent flexibility of many contemporary buildings gives occupants the freedom to change their use of space, which may mean that the building services need to be adjusted or re-commissioned.
Continuous commissioning is made easier with the use of addressable control systems. Adjustments to lighting and heating and cooling setpoints can be made via a central computer, reducing the cost and disruption that often comes with conventional commissioning activities. This is typically a task that would come under a maintenance contract, although it can be useful to involve the original commissioning engineers.
All these activities make the gradual handover of full control of the building from the services and commissioning engineers to the facilities management team flow more easily. It gives the facilities team the chance to get to know the systems fully, hopefully with the experts on hand to train and assist with problems that may arise.
From reviewing the processes used during the design, construction and occupation of the LCBP buildings, it appears that many people have the right intentions with regard to commissioning. However, with the traditional forms of contracts still in place, and practical completion and handover being the focal point of the project, commissioning is still often squeezed into a short period. Using a graduated handover approach, where the building is given time to settle down and enough time is allowed to commission all systems fully, is hugely beneficial to the client.
At the Canolfan Rheidol building in Wales, the fuel delivery system for the Binder biomass boiler consists of several augers and associated pumps. Initially, the system broke down several times forcing reliance on the gas back-up boiler. Fortunately the client maintained a good relationship with the biomass boiler supplier. The Canolfan Rheidol project also demonstrated the wisdom of holding spares in stock, as lead times from overseas suppliers can be lengthy.
The headquarters building for Ceredigion County Council is naturally ventilated via motorised toplights in each window in the office areas, and motorised louvres in the atrium to promote stack ventilation. There was initially a problem with the atrium louvres driving fully when the window toplights only opened a small amount. Feedback from occupants helped to identify and solve the problem.
This article originally appeared in Delta T Magazine May 2011, written by BSRIA’s James Parker. It was posted here by --BSRIA 08:31, 26 November 2014 (UTC).
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings
- At your services - What to expect during commissioning.
- Client commissioning.
- Commissioning.
- Commissioning documents.
- Commissioning notice.
- Commissioning plan.
- Commissioning planning.
- Commissioning v testing.
- Continuous commissioning.
- Initial commissioning case studies.
- Practical completion.
- Requirements management.
- Seasonal commissioning.
- Soft landings.
- Specialist commissioning manager.
- Training for pre-commissioning cleaning of pipework systems.
Featured articles and news
The continued ISG fall out, where to go?
Support for ISG contractors, companies and employees.
New HES national centre for traditional building retrofit
Announced as HES publishes survey results which reveal strong support for retrofit.
Retrofit of Buildings, a CIOB Technical Publication
Expected to become one of the largest activities in the global construction industry.
The ECA industry focus video channel
Keeping update with the industry session by session.
Over 25 recorded informations sessions freely available.
AT Awards 2024 ceremony East London October 25th.
Revisiting the AT community at the 2023 awards evening.
The Community Housing Fund and built affordable homes
CLTN reviews the impact of the Fund and calls for extension.
The grading system of the Regulator for Social Housing
A background, an explanation and ten recent enforcements.
Construction, repair and maintenance. Book review.
Putting new life into a city with a 1900 year history.
BSRIA Briefing 2024: Sustainable Futures speakers
Redefining Retrofit for Net Zero Living 22 Nov.
Wall of support for post-Grenfell regulation of electricians
Call for a shake-up of the construction industry highlighted on radio.
Digital sustainability through future AEC tools
Bringing together industry and academia to meet challenges.
Skills gap for net zero highlighted to Minister for Industry
ECA convenes roundtable discussion at Portcullis House.
Evidencing Net Zero with the new UK buildings standard
Pilot version with detailed excel proforma out now!
Scottish Building Safety Levy, in consultation
From direct remediation and the RPDT, to the costs and alternatives.
Waves of warmer homes grants for the rental sector
Boosting energy efficiency standards for all rented homes.
A refocus of the National Planning Policy Framework
Key terms described in brief, as the consultation closes the evening of the 24th.
Fortified farmhouses of the unruly 16th-and 17th-century borders.