Brasilia Syndrome
Contents |
[edit] Introduction
Brasilia Syndrome (also known as Helicopter Urbanism or Birdshit Architecture) is a term introduced by Jan Gehl to describe certain types of urban planning that became popular in the 1950s and is still in use. These developments look impressive from a bird’s eye view but fail to function effectively - and may be unwelcoming - for those people who experience the cities at ground level. Gehl feels that Brasilia Syndrome most often occurs when the larger, more remote scale is emphasised while the smaller, human scale is disregarded.
Gehl places some of the blame on two contemporary trends - modernist architecture and the car culture mentality. Gehl suggests that plans are created by those who are looking from high above and are dropped to the ground with no regard for those below. This vantage point - from a helicopter, airplane or drone - may be impressive, but at ground level, layouts fail to factor in distances and experiences for those who must live, work, walk and cycle through them.
[edit] Observing people in cities
Gehl is a Danish architect and urban planner who has written about Brasilia Syndrome based on observations he made while analysing human behaviour in cities. He noted that people preferred to collect around the edges of cities rather than gather in the open.
In a series of studies, he gathered data to help him confirm or deny his theory. Thee statistics reinforced his observations and found that cycle-friendly, human-scaled cities (such as Copenhagen) provide a completely different experience for their inhabitants. By contrast, Brasilia Syndrome cities, such as Dubai, fail from the perspective of those who experience them as pedestrians or cyclists.
These geometric, car-centric plans are made up of buildings that lack detail and are typically in straight, monotonous lines. This may be optimal for motorised vehicles, but it is unnatural for pedestrians or cyclists (particularly when compared to ancient cities like Rome, where there are practically no straight lines).
Poor public space is often discussed in terms of the negative effects of the modern idiom, in which coherent urban fabric is replaced by buildings as objects, which fail to define space and result in a reduction in quality in what Gehl calls ‘life between buildings’. Instead, Gehl feels that cities should be designed where people - not cars or buildings - serve as the starting point for sustainable living spaces.
[edit] Case study: Brasilia
The capital of Brazil is namesake behind Helicopter Urbanism. It was planned in the mid 1950s by Lúcio Costa, Oscar Niemeyer and Joaquim Cardozo and was specifically designed as the country’s new capital.
Before the city was established, the area resembled a desert. It was conceived as a practical utopia with Oscar Niemeyer designing hundreds of buildings. There are several designated sectors - a hotel sector, a banking sector, an embassy sector and so on - with specific purposes. The architecture is predominantly modernist, and the city was named as a UNESCO World Heritage Site in recognition of its architecture and urban planning.
From the air, Brasilia is impressively designed in the shape of an eagle. The sector of white government buildings is situated at the eagle’s head, and the residential housing blocks are arranged in neighbourhoods around green areas and placed in the eagle's wings.
Satellite image of Brasilia.
While Brasilia has received accolades for its urban planning, it is not generally thought of as a successful arrangement by its residents. The scale is considered too spread out to be practical. Pedestrians and cyclists reject walkways that are too long, formal and monotonous. Instead, they opt to walk and cycle across the green areas, creating their own organic, human-centric trails.
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
Featured articles and news
The continued ISG fall out, where to go?
Support for ISG contractors, companies and employees.
New HES national centre for traditional building retrofit
Announced as HES publishes survey results which reveal strong support for retrofit.
Retrofit of Buildings, a CIOB Technical Publication
Expected to become one of the largest activities in the global construction industry.
The ECA industry focus video channel
Keeping update with the industry session by session.
Over 25 recorded informations sessions freely available.
AT Awards 2024 ceremony East London October 25th.
Revisiting the AT community at the 2023 awards evening.
The Community Housing Fund and built affordable homes
CLTN reviews the impact of the Fund and calls for extension.
The grading system of the Regulator for Social Housing
A background, an explanation and ten recent enforcements.
Construction, repair and maintenance. Book review.
Putting new life into a city with a 1900 year history.
BSRIA Briefing 2024: Sustainable Futures speakers
Redefining Retrofit for Net Zero Living 22 Nov.
Wall of support for post-Grenfell regulation of electricians
Call for a shake-up of the construction industry highlighted on radio.
Digital sustainability through future AEC tools
Bringing together industry and academia to meet challenges.
Skills gap for net zero highlighted to Minister for Industry
ECA convenes roundtable discussion at Portcullis House.
Evidencing Net Zero with the new UK buildings standard
Pilot version with detailed excel proforma out now!
Scottish Building Safety Levy, in consultation
From direct remediation and the RPDT, to the costs and alternatives.
Waves of warmer homes grants for the rental sector
Boosting energy efficiency standards for all rented homes.
A refocus of the National Planning Policy Framework
Key terms described in brief, as the consultation closes the evening of the 24th.
Fortified farmhouses of the unruly 16th-and 17th-century borders.