Campaign for cash retentions reform
![]() |
A total of 271 MPs across all parties support the reform of cash retentions. |
Contents |
[edit] Introduction
Cash retentions are monies held back by larger contractors and clients from subcontractors where issues of non-performance arise, such as defects arising on work undertaken.
Retentions are held by private and public sector clients against their subcontractors, with over £10.5bn of SME working capital locked in retentions annually. Some £7.8 billion of this has been unpaid in the last three years.
However, the system is often abused, negatively impacting many businesses in construction, particularly SMEs.
As a result, ECA, BESA and various partner organisations have been pressing Government to reform this practice. Reform of cash retentions in construction is now supported by a broad range of politicians, business bodies, construction trade associations, and professional bodies.
[edit] Impact of retentions
Deprivation of working capital leaves businesses unable to grow (bid for new work), invest (engineering R&D and investment in digital transformation), recruit (new workers and apprentices), pay tax bills, and therefore precludes productivity improvement.
As retention monies are not protected, ring-fenced or held in trust, if a contractor goes bust, the money is lost by subcontractors, and goes to other creditors, often outside the industry.
In the UK, recent government research shows £700m of retentions were lost from upstream insolvency over a three-year period (prior to the collapse of Carillion). For each working day, the industry loses almost £1m, £4.5m per week or £20m per month.
Research has found that SMEs spend on average 130 hours per year chasing late payment from larger firms. And 34% of SMEs borrow to cover cash-flow issues caused by cash retentions. Often this is written off as bad debt, due to the resource implications of chasing monies due.
Cash flow issues leave businesses unable to:
- bid for new work
- take on new workers and apprentices
- pay tax bills, and
- improve productivity.
The knock-on effects of cash retentions can also include stress and mental health issues.
The current system is also a causal factor in bringing about a less efficient public procurement system and results in lower tax receipts for the public purse.
[edit] About this article
This article is an amalgamation of two articles that first appeared on the website of the Electrical Contractors’ Association (ECA) in March 2019: 'About the campaign' can be accessed here ; the 'Impact of retentions' can be accesed here.
--ECA
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
- Retention bond
- Retention in construction contracts
- Defects liability period DLP
- Construction (Retention Deposit Schemes) Bill 2017-19
- Performance bond for construction
- Defects in construction
- Bonds in construction contracts
- ECA articles
- Final account
- Final certificate for construction contracts
- Liquidated damages in construction contracts
- Valuation of interim payments
- Right to payment
- Variations in construction contracts
- Contract sum
- Domestic sub-contractor
- Insolvency in the construction industry
[edit] External references
- Construction Manager, 20 November 2017, 60% of engineering firms say turnover is held in retentions.
Featured articles and news
Designing sustainability and performance into buildings
Specifying and selecting sustainable resilient timber products.
Modifying wood to improve resistance to decay and movement.
A last minute, long look for built environment professionals.
The architecture of creative reuse. Book review.
Installing solar panels on listed structures.
Sustainable development global goals, history in progress?
"Unless we act now, the 2030 Agenda will become an epitaph for a world that might have been."
Mike Kagioglou FCIOB named CIOB President
'Sustainable Development Goals must be focus for construction'
BSRIA training; a look at what's on offer
From energy management to compliance training.
TESP video warns to beware of rogue trainers.
Highlighting the slippery tactics of non-approved providers.
New Building Safety Wiki launched
Boosting awareness and understanding of the new fire safety regime.
New playbook on AI in construction published by CIOB
How to get to grips with, and the best from AI.
Digital Construction Report NBS
BIM, cloud, off-site, immersive tech, AI, twins and sustainability.
ECA learning zone and industry focus video series
From updates and amendments to circular economy, emergency lighting and much more.
The Building People Communities Network
Celebrating and amplifying voices of the under-represented, this refugee week and pride month.
Pride of Place: queer heritage
Acknowledging and taking pride in LGBTQ histories.