Legislation needed in response to the role of retentions in company insolvency
Speaking to Construction News this week, in the article "Failure to ban retentions ‘contributing to insolvencies’ ECA Director of Legal and Business Rob Driscoll warned of the continued impact of retentions on sub-contractors, unless new legislation is brought in to reform the practice.The article reports that the continued use of retentions in the construction industry is contributing to company failures and insolvencies.
Cash retentions are deducted from payments owed in respect of labour, materials and works already delivered and carried out, and therefore legally belong to the companies that carried out the work. Retentions are on average worth 5% of a contract's total value, but can be up to 20%.
Rob Driscoll said, “With no policy or position in place from government to reform retentions, this long-running bone of contention will fail to be resolved and continue to inhibit productivity and performance by the industry. We know that if economic performance in construction declines, cash flow is squeezed and insolvencies rise.”
The CLC previously had an ambition of abolishing retentions from the industry by 2025, though this has since been dropped. CLC co-chair Mark Reynolds and deputy co-chair Richard Robinson agreed to work further on issues around retentions with Isabel Coman, a director at Transport for London and CLC board member. "With no policy in place to remove retentions, it will make it more difficult for organisations, particularly with the number of companies going into administration increasing and so much cash they need being held back” Ms Coman was quoted as having said.
The government has said it wants the industry to come to a consensus on the issue itself, most recently in a House of Lords debate in December. Lord Malcolm Offord said: “Our long-term aim is to remove the need for retentions altogether.” He explained that the government supported academic work that aims to develop “a quality metric as a viable alternative to the withholding of cash retentions as a form of insurance against defects. We are working with the industry and a lot of consideration has been given to this matter but, ultimately, the construction industry itself needs to come to a consensus on how to improve this area.”
In response, Liberal Democrat Lord Andrew Stunell said ministers were asking for “the greedy lions to sit down with the defenceless lambs and decide what menu is going to be eaten. The reality is that the upper-tier contractors have not just the whip hand but the bank balance. He will know that many of them have a business model that functions only because they retain retentions to which they are not legally entitled.”
The full article, Failure to ban retentions ‘contributing to insolvencies’ published by Construction News can be found here
--ECA
This article is based on the article published on the ECA news and blog "ECA's Rob Driscoll speaks to Construction News about insolvencies", dated January 30, 2023 and extracts from the original article "Failure to ban retentions ‘contributing to insolvencies’ " published by Construction News dated January 29, 2023.
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings
- Bonds in construction contracts.
- Campaign for cash retentions reform.
- Certificate of making good defects.
- Construction (Retention Deposit Schemes) Bill 2017-19.
- Defects liability period DLP.
- ECA articles.
- Failure to complete construction works.
- Final account.
- Final certificate.
- Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act HGRA.
- Insolvency in the construction industry.
- Interim certificates in construction contracts.
- Liquidated damages in construction contracts.
- Performance bond for construction.
- Practical completion.
- Project bank account.
- Retention in construction contracts.
- Retention bond.
- Right to payment.
- Valuation of interim payments.
Featured articles and news
HSE simplified advice for installers of stone worktops
After company fined for repeatedly failing to protect workers.
Co-located with 10th year of UK Construction Week.
How orchards can influence planning and development.
Time for knapping, no time for napping
Decorative split stone square patterns in facades.
A practical guide to the use of flint in design and architecture.
Designing for neurodiversity: driving change for the better
Accessible inclusive design translated into reality.
RIBA detailed response to Grenfell Inquiry Phase 2 report
Briefing notes following its initial 4 September response.
Approved Document B: Fire Safety from March
Current and future changes with historical documentation.
A New Year, a new look for BSRIA
As phase 1 of the BSRIA Living Laboratory is completed.
A must-attend event for the architecture industry.
Caroline Gumble to step down as CIOB CEO in 2025
After transformative tenure take on a leadership role within the engineering sector.
RIDDOR and the provisional statistics for 2023 / 2024
Work related deaths; over 50 percent from construction and 50 percent recorded as fall from height.
Solar PV company fined for health and safety failure
Work at height not properly planned and failure to take suitable steps to prevent a fall.
The term value when assessing the viability of developments
Consultation on the compulsory purchase process, compensation reforms and potential removal of hope value.
Trees are part of the history of how places have developed.