The overlooked secret of off-site fabrication
Off-site manufacture, pre-fabrication, modular construction, whatever it is called it has been heralded as a win:win:win solution for construction.
Through the provision of cost effective building elements and units, which require fewer deliveries to site and offers a better finish quality with less waste – what can possibly be said against the growth of this modern method of construction?
Over the last couple of years, KLH Sustainability has been asked to evaluate a variety of modular construction solutions, and although we largely agree with the rhetoric and have been able to prove significant benefits of modular construction over conventional concrete frame constructions, something isn’t adding up.
The benefits we have calculated for the modular construction of a complete building versus traditional concrete frame construction include:
- Over 45% reduction in material use.
- Over 50% reduction in waste generation. Over 40% reduction in HGV movements at the construction site.
For modular buildings, this magnitude of benefits does require the modular solution to be explored and implemented at the early stages of design so that the lightweighting of the superstructure can be translated into reduced foundations.
We have observed the improved finish quality and the quicker, safer site construction. We are also, of course very supportive of the potential creation of new jobs in construction away from the construction site, jobs that may appeal more to diverse engineers and workers who want more consistency in job location and working hours.
So where is the issue? Carbon.
In the assessments we have undertaken to date the carbon impact for the modular solution does not balance, even if the reduced site deliveries, reduced waste and reduced construction programme are taken into account.
We have calculated the additional carbon impact of modular construction of buildings to be around 20%, although for some individual building elements it may be over 100%.
So, where is all this carbon coming from?
We have found that there is significantly more structural support within modular units to cope with the stresses of transportation and lifting into position on site than is required for the structural stability of the building. This additional structural support is often integral to the units, and is fabricated from that carbon hungry material--steel.
There are some interesting solutions out there. One we observed in central London, took the form of a bespoke, reusable lifting frame for double height mansard thereby allowing the units themselves to be constructed without excess bracing.
Perhaps lightweight fibre reinforced plastic can provide some of the additional structural integrity required in pre-fabricated units? Or low-carbon timber solutions exist?
The carbon balance for modular construction may be found in the improved operational performance of modular buildings. Factory facilities should enable units to be constructed with better U-values and air-tightness and potentially reduce the energy performance gap of our buildings. However, until this is accurately assessed and quantified it is difficult to claim modular buildings can deliver a better life-cycle carbon than conventional construction techniques.
The carbon impact does not, and should not be a show-stopper for modular construction. However, it is an aspect that should not be forgotten by those developing modular construction solutions. At KLH we know that sustainability is about more than just carbon, but equally carbon is not a factor that can be ignored.
[edit] Find out more
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
Featured articles and news
Quality Planning for Micro and Small to Medium Sized Enterprises
A CIOB Academy Technical Information sheet.
A briefing on fall protection systems for designers
A legal requirement and an ethical must.
CIOB Ireland launches manifesto for 2024 General Election
A vision for a sustainable, high-quality built environment that benefits all members of society.
Local leaders gain new powers to support local high streets
High Street Rental Auctions to be introduced from December.
Infrastructure sector posts second gain for October
With a boost for housebuilder and commercial developer contract awards.
Sustainable construction design teams survey
Shaping the Future of Sustainable Design: Your Voice Matters.
COP29; impacts of construction and updates
Amid criticism, open letters and calls for reform.
The properties of conservation rooflights
Things to consider when choosing the right product.
Adapting to meet changing needs.
London Build: A festival of construction
Co-located with the London Build Fire & Security Expo.
Tasked with locating groups of 10,000 homes with opportunity.
Delivering radical reform in the UK energy market
What are the benefits, barriers and underlying principles.
Information Management Initiative IMI
Building sector-transforming capabilities in emerging technologies.
Recent study of UK households reveals chilling home truths
Poor insulation, EPC knowledge and lack of understanding as to what retrofit might offer.
Embodied Carbon in the Built Environment
Overview, regulations, detail calculations and much more.
Why the construction sector must embrace workplace mental health support
Let’s talk; more importantly now, than ever.
Ensuring the trustworthiness of AI systems
A key growth area, including impacts for construction.