Correct service charge procedures
Residential leases usually contain detailed procedures that must be followed before valid demands for service charges can be raised. Some landlords sidestep such requirements for reasons of convenience, but an Upper Tribunal (UT) decision has underlined the hazards inherent in such a course.
The case of Jetha & Anr v Basildon Court Residents Company Limited (2017) concerned a prestigious block of 56 flats, the common parts of which were owned by a services company.
The tenants of 11 of those flats had refused to pay service charges due to various concerns about the property’s management. The company launched proceedings to recover arrears of more than £40,000.
The First-tier Tribunal (FTT) found that the lease did not provide for the collection of interim service charges on account. Those charges and contributions to a sinking fund maintained by the company had not been agreed at an annual general meeting (AGM), as required by the lease.
The FTT, however, found that the disputed bills were payable on the basis that the procedure employed by the company was well established and the tenants had never objected to it in the past.
In upholding the tenants’ challenge to the latter ruling, the UT noted that the requirement that service charges be approved by a majority at an AGM was an important safeguard. It was neither unfair nor unjust for the tenants to rely upon the letter of the lease and, in the circumstances, the disputed bills were not payable.
[edit] Find out more
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
Featured articles and news
Listed despite problems with its design.
Zen and the art of cycling exploration.
Design Council Homes Taskforce launched
To support government 1.5 million homes target within UK climate commitments.
The story of this knowledge quarter building.
In ecology, in hydrology, in biology and in architecture.
Creating environments that promote physical, mental, and social well-being.
UK cases of neutral current diversion
Research project looks for example contributions.
Overstocking and macro-economics cause a decline.
The 2024 update of the Common Assessment Standard
Demonstrating organisational capability’ to fulfil roles under the Building Safety Act.
56 recommendations for a better built environment
Published by the CIC ahead of the King’s Speech.
SkillELECTRIC Top 8 Competitors Named
in annual search for the UK’s best student electrician.
CIOB Diversity and Inclusion technical information sheet
Step-by-step guide on implementing D and I practices.
Conservation and the Indian City. Book review.
Reversibility in conservation ethics
Learning from painting conservation.
Where It's AT Podcast launched!
New CIAT Architectural Technology Podcast goes live.