Designing for pedestrians
The issues around pedestrian characteristics and practical design to see how people can be encouraged to walk more.
Contents |
[edit] Introduction
In the UK, the safety and convenience of walking has, except for some notable recent exceptions, decreased considerably. A tenfold increase in the motor vehicle fleet, the associated spreading of suburbs and proportional decline in public transport have all contributed to this decline.
Transport infrastructure is often based on the 1930s notions of motor vehicle convenience. Notably, the UK has the worst pedestrian death rate compared to all road deaths of Western European countries.
More dramatically, in the UK about 400 pedestrians are killed each year and another 4,500 seriously injured – equivalent to a jumbo jet crashing each year with all killed and another crashing each month with all seriously injured. A further nearly 15,000 are ‘slightly’ injured.
On a personal level, perceived dangers have resulted in more car use for transporting children to school and for recreation. Also, many disabled and elderly people are deterred from making essential visits to shops, accessing public transport, visiting medical facilities and meeting friends and making other vital social interactions – all essential to health, wellbeing and economic independence.
[edit] The need for more walking
As civil engineers are largely responsible for fixed transport infrastructure, perhaps we should be asking whether this safety record is acceptable.
Along with other disciplines, the need for a solid performance basis in our transport system is fundamental - as with any other realm of human activity. The need for greater independence from motorised travel is linked closely with issues ranging from climate change and urban design to legislative processes and access for disabled people – all involving engineering inputs to ensure optimum success.
[edit] Areas of concern
A wide variety of sources of information is available to engineers and others responsible for planning, implementing, maintaining and improving pedestrian facilities. The design and engineering guidance typically addressed by governmental agencies at national, county, and local levels may be influenced by professional organisations, and local, regional, and national interest groups.
Together with targeted research, various changes are evolving. Yet certain basic, possibly cultural, assumptions pervade the basic engineering approach to design.
One of the key aspects in this is that drivers are the key elements of actions to avoid collisions. Virtually no consideration is given to the fact that drivers are fallible so that designs should enable pedestrians to be in control of their own safety.
Possibly, this approach is exacerbated by the almost complete lack of coordination of advice given in the Highway Code with official design guidance.
One example of this is that in the design guidance for junctions, the designer is recommended to figuratively ‘drive through‘ the proposed design, yet no mention is made of the need for pedestrians to ‘walk through’ the design.
[edit] Engineering pedestrian facilities
Design of pedestrian facilities is not extensively taught in university engineering courses, and at best is usually considered an add-on to design of streets and highways.
The detailed, numerically defined, characteristics of drivers’ reaction times, acceleration and deceleration rates, and vehicle dimensions – all essential bases for drivers safety - are rarely, if at all, considered for pedestrians, yet are equally, if not more important for designing for the latter’s safety and convenience.
A consequence of this approach is that the engineering of pedestrian facilities, including that to accommodate disabled people in accordance with the Disability Act of 2010, has serious deficiencies.
[edit] Current practice and the way ahead
Typical characteristics traditionally considered in designing for pedestrians include; basic movement patterns, physical design features such as roundabouts, junction configuration, crossing features, signal timing, and interaction with other non-motorised users.
Continuing research and examination of current design assumptions, methods, and new approaches to pedestrian movement are currently being adopted. Among these are; new and modified street configurations to reduce vehicle speeds and encourage pedestrian movement, combined pedestrian and bicycle routes, measurement methods to determine levels of service and auditing of new and existing facilities.
A number of significant movements, official recognition of interest groups promoting non-motorised transport and recognition of environmental issues are addressing key concerns.
One example is the Institution of Civil Engineers’ publication describing both theoretical and practical aspects and titled Pedestrian Facilities by John Schoon. This book is now in its second edition. Hopefully, it will contribute to the safety and convenience of walking and its associated benefits to individuals and to society at large.
John George Schoon has experience in consulting in multi-modal transportation planning in several countries for private firms and the United Nations, and in traffic accident reconstruction, research, lecturing and student project supervision. He has authored numerous reports and technical papers, including those on pedestrian facilities and inclusive mobility.
This article was originally published on the ICE Civil engineering blog on 19 September 2019.
--The Institution of Civil Engineers
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings
- Accessibility in the built environment.
- Approved document M.
- BREEAM Transport Assessment and Travel Plan.
- Changing lifestyles in the built environment.
- Close proximity.
- Compliant public transport node.
- Healthy Streets.
- ICE articles.
- Pedestrianised.
- Pedestrian shed.
- Safe pedestrian route.
- Step free.
- The Institution of Civil Engineers.
- Types of road and street.
- Walking distance.
- Walkway.
Featured articles and news
Tackling the lack of knowledge or confidence in heat pumps
The CICV Green Home Festival part of the Edinburgh Fringe.
Home improvements swapped for green energy upgrades
As applications down since and desire to reduce bills up.
Eco apprenticeships continue help grow green workforce
A year after being recognised at the King's coronation.
The Use of Natural Insulation Materials in Retrofit
New paper from STBA with support from SDF.
National Retrofit Hub in partnership with InstallerSHOW.
Permitted development rights for agricultural buildings
The changes coming into effect as of May 21, 2024.
Biodiversity and the built environment digital series
The nature of building, with CIOB and CWP.
A call for prevention and sensitive re-use.
Risks to the long-term effectiveness of the BNG scheme
National Audit Office publish review of Biodiversity Net Gain.
The CIAT principal designer register
Providing assurance and verification of the capability and competence of registered ATs.
Building Safety recommendations and Northern Ireland
The NI roadmap to improving safety in high rise residential.
Specifying rendered external wall insulation for fire safety
How to interrogate the evidence provided to the specifier.
The benefits of writing articles for your organisation
How to create a profile for your organisation and publish for free.
No Falls Week. The importance of safe working at height
What to expect and what is on offer to avoid accidents.
Scottish Government action to reach net-zero targets
Retrofit expert group highlight critical actions needed.
A forward thinking, inclusive global community of members.